User blog comment:Webly/Read About revival but this time by Webleh/@comment-1773274-20120326013838/@comment-1874924-20120326032138

My experience with story talk pages is that few stories routinely get comments in the level of detail that you seem to be asking for, so I'd say your problem is probably the rule rather than the exception. I've got a Featured Story with something like 4 talk page comments other than my own, and no long ones. Most readers don't even look at the talk pages, let alone comment on them. That's the main reason why I kept nominating the story for FS--that's how I was getting my feedback.