User blog comment:Rhonda the stalker fan!/Total Drama 30 Day Challenge: Day 3/@comment-1441098-20180704150410

It’s really tough to decide between TDI and RR. I usually lean towards saying TDI just because it was the first season, the one that got me into the whole show, and had this kind of magic they were never really able to replicate, but then I think about how RR felt so fresh and creative and just plain fun. Plus, Island had some early installment weirdness going on between some big plot holes and some of the characters not getting too much focus, while I’d say none of the RR teams were shafted except some very, very early boots and the plots felt a lot more natural and coherent.

So it’s super hard and my answer routinely changes, but for now I’ll say Island. They’ve never had as much success in the Survivor format since (I’m not nearly as high on WT as most people because even though that first stretch from Egypt to London is my favorite stretch in the series, it takes a HUGE nosedive in quality after Noah and Tyler leave and they start focusing on the same old tired garbage + Gollum Zeke for the rest of the season), and sometimes my feelings towards TDI remind me of certain Pokemon fans’ feelings towards Kanto. So yeah, let’s go TDI.