User blog comment:JoFanForever/Total Drama: Season 5 help? My first fanfiction?/@comment-1874924-20110807014304

I don't think Gwen is really antagonist material. She can be passive-aggressive, but I'm not sure she has enough initiative to hatch the sort of schemes that one would expect from a main antagonist. Maybe that's why you find her boring?

Since you're going to be using characters who have been on the show before, I think the main antagonist should be someone with a chip on their shoulder and a score to settle. Courtney, maybe? I'm confident that you--or, for that matter, almost anyone else here--could do a better job with her in that role than the canon TDA writers did.

On the other hand, if you want something really offbeat, how about Katie and Sadie as the main antagonists? Think about it...do we really know what lurks beneath those sweet exteriors? And they haven't been in the game since Season 1...