User blog comment:Rhonda the stalker fan!/Total Drama 30 Day Challenge: Day 24/@comment-1034367-20180730234738

in terms of stories that I've actually read (sorry to Zac/Bruno/Mana/others who will then be left out of this by default oops), the early-game Sprinklemist and Nalyd fanfics were solid – Total Drama: Boney Island/Total Drama Reality /Total Drama Amazon/Total Drama All-Stars were some of the most compelling to follow stories on the wiki at the time of writing. The Legend of Total Drama Island is really cool due to its premise, and Rhonda/Toad are doing/have done a great job with making Total Drama Genesis/Total Drama: Superstar Showdown funny and interesting.

In terms of non-competitive stories, at the time of its release/peak of its fandom, Life After Lies was incredibly gripping. Looking back, like, yeah, it wasn't game-changing and has flaws, but that hooked me big time in middle school.