User blog comment:Owenandheatherfan/The Official Total Drama Character Competition of 2013; Round 1 - Duncan vs. Scott/@comment-1874924-20130217072928

These are two of my least favorite characters of the lot. The Season 2 Duncan was little more than a bully and the Season 1 Duncan wasn't much better; but the Season 1/3 Duncan at least had a coherent strategy, which is more than can be said for Scott. The sheer absurdity of Scott's so-called "strategy" left Season 4 without a believable antagonist. Devious? more like demented. He could have been so much more.

I'd rather vote no on both; but since that's not an option, I'll have to go with Duncan.