User blog comment:Rhonda the stalker fan!/Total Drama 30 Day Challenge: Day 28/@comment-1874924-20180802051617/@comment-3350823-20180802181322

I think this is the answer right here. I think if we do ever have another season with returning players that the more central characters are lesser used characters (RR did this with Noah, and I guess Geoff to an extent, so I have some hope for them).

I LOVE this idea for a RR final two!!! The light vs darkness matchup is a great idea. I'd probably root for the Goths too, but if the writers made Katie and Sadie rootable throughout the rest of the season then I might be swayed...

I actually think Katie and Sadie have somewhat undeserved reputation has the worst characters from Island; you've mentioned before the theory that Sadie's VA was largely unavailable, leading to her becoming invisible. But I never found the characters too annoying in the original Island, and they had some good comedy moments. If the writers would write them as more fun/ditzy and prone to less arguing, I could definitely see it working. I mean if they're at least like a female version of the Surfer Bros that's enough for me, though I think they could be more.

I feel like Don could potentially get annoyed with Katie and Sadie, but he'd still prefer them to the Goths. The idea of the Goths and Katie and Sadie interacting just sounds like a fun idea; a Superteam challenge forcing them to work together would be comedy gold.