User blog comment:Sprinklemist/Main Story Six (and some other) Announcements. Opinions Wanted!/@comment-4669666-20110112000815

Here are my choices for Second All-Stars:

Boney Island: Zane, Stevie, Levi, Missy, Grace

Reality: Micky D., Tsuyoshi, iRene, Val, Ruth

Tropics: Dante, Sebastian, Audrey II, Marguerite, Topher

Wilderness: Eduardo, Brad, Yesenia, Joanna, Tamira

If you want to reuse characters from the first All-Stars, I'd use Kendall, Fiona, and Francesca