User blog comment:1dra7/Battle For The Drama Round Two: Katie vs Sadie/@comment-1874924-20130623031403

Katie's prettier by most widely accepted standards (although there's a period known in the art world as "the fat century", during which Sadie and Staci would have been considered the hottest girls on the island). Otherwise, there's not much to choose. The pseudo-canonical text bios on the show's website state that Katie thinks with her heart, and Sadie with her head. If any of that had made it into the actual show, this would have been a more interesting choice.