User blog comment:Fedora Kid/Total Drama Wiki's Hall of Fame - Total Drama Action/@comment-12762816-20131216193625/@comment-1734566-20131220172359

Sorry, Drfiz. But a majority of these points are kinda flawed.

1: "She jumped off the cilef with ease with her best friend." - She was originally refusing to jump, and thus cost her team another point, if she couldn't do so without Sadie. And even then, keep in mind; a vast majority of the campers did jump. So what makes Katie and Sadie so special?

2: "ven if with her posion Ivey she actually helped with building the hottube." - Um, it was because of them sitting in poison ivy that they slowed the team down in the first place, among other things. And how did they contribute to the hot tub with anything? They were never seen actively helping to build it. And any contribution they did make only resulted in it collapsing at the very end.

3: "She was the first female to ever get a marshmallow." - Um...so? How does this make her a strong competitor? It was by mere chance that Chris happened to say her name before any other girls' name.

4: "and her Sadie lasted more than half of the night in The Big Sleep." - Still roughly half, that's just an average performance.

5: "In Dogebrawl she played in every game and did well in all. She got out like 5 people in the game." - So what if she was in every round? The Bass were still sucking every round she was in, and they only won when Duncan stepped in. And it's worth noting that she didn't really start to eliminate people until after Duncan provided his prison strategy, which involved her working with other members of the Bass.

6: "In the fashion contest she was dancing well and would of been in the talent show if Bridgette didn't puke on her." - That's subjective as to whether or not her dancing was good. In your opinion, it was. In others', it wasn't. And she was never going to be in the talent show. Remember? They originally settled on DJ, Bridgette, and Courtney. Courtney was only replaced with Harold after her violin broke.

7: "In The Sucky Outdoors she got a lot development and was just very unlikly" - So what if she got development? This is focusing on the characters as competitors, not as characters. And what development did she get? Nothing really, just arguing with Sadie. And she "was just very unlikly." Um. What? Unlikely, how? You mean...her character is unlikely? This doesn't make any sense. O.o

8: "She found the bear cave and was easily able to sleep in there." - So? They were still lost and separated from their team. This is like putting a band-aid on a broken leg.

9: "They reached the camp like 5 seconded after very one else and was allmost saved." - But the fact is, they weren't saved. They lost. Their team lost because of them. It doesn't matter how quickly they showed up, they still showed up after the Gophers and the rest of their team.

10: "She had a lot lines in Playa De Losers" - Um, so? Once again, a bunch of lines does not merit a good competitor. You made this same claim with your nomination for Eva. So what if they have a ton of lines? Talk is talk, not action.

11: "would have found the case if they weren't crazy over Justin." - There's no proof of this. Sure, Justin sticking them in a cave greatly hindered their progress, but there's no evidence to suggest that they would've done any better had they not been left behind, since they were crappy competitors.

All in all, the most that these flawed points can ad up to is that Katie may have been a mediocre competitor at best, and definitely a bland character. There's still no way you can say she was one of the strongest players in TDI, let alone the strongest player. This is like me trying to defend Ezekiel. I may love him as a character, but I'll never defend his performance in the competition, because it was so minimal.