User blog comment:AverageHero/The True All-Stars./@comment-4368235-20130830164224/@comment-2228839-20130830172116

Beth, while maybe not the most interesting by some standards, should be an All-Star since she did make the Final 2, and won in some countries.

Blaineley would better suit as an aftermath host, so I don't think she's an All-Star, despite how amazing she is. <3

Cody shouldn't be an all-star just for the fact the he went pre-merge in TDI, and in TDWT, was carried by Sierra. If Sierra wasn't there to defend him, he probably would have been the first boot of Team Amazon.

DJ isn't an all-star, in my opinion. In TDI, he made the merge, but in TDA he quit, and in TDWT, kept trying to get himself eliminated.

Harold is an All-Star, but probably couldn't fit into a Hero or Villain category. In TDI he was picked on, but pulled probably one of the most villainous moves ever by rigging the votes. However, in the next two seasons, he was a hero. So where does he fall? I don't know. But he'd be an All-Star without the Heroes and Villains concept.

Trent.... No.

Tyler, in my opinion, isn't an All-Star, but he could definitely fit a Hero role, so it more depends on how others feel. So he could be, just not in my eyes.

Also, I'm against Dawn being an All-Star. Sure, she was popular, but she practically did nothing in 3/5 of her episodes. She's definitely a fan-favorite, but a far stretch for All-Stars. (But she could fit a Hero role, or the Dark Horse role that usually is in many All-Star type seasons).