User blog comment:JERealize/Totally Dramatic Awards - Nominations/@comment-1874924-20130105081554

A few potential problems:


 * 1) I strongly suggest that you not give awards for anything that you don't want to encourage people to do more of. For that reason, "Most Controversial Sockpuppet" and "Biggest Spammer" are both extremely bad ideas.
 * 2) The only reason I can see for calling it "Best Breakout User" instead of "Best New User" is if you also want to allow nominations of old users who made an impact in 2012 after previously not doing much.
 * 3) For most of the story categories, you need to clarify whether nominations must be finished stories or new stories, or whether any story that had chapters posted during the year is eligible.
 * 4) If these awards are intended to replace the Wiki Awards, then you need to clarify whether stories and characters that won last year are eligible to repeat in the same categories. This is only an issue if you're trying to replace the Wiki Awards.
 * 5) You might want to consider only giving awards in categories that have at least two nominees, as was done with the Wiki Awards.