These are the most popular stories from the wiki's first two years (sometimes known as the "Golden Age"):
- Endurance, by Fanfiction2010
- Legacy, by Gideoncrawle
- Life After Lies, by Fadingsilverstar16
- Return to Total Drama Island, by TDIwriter
- Total Drama All-Stars, by Nalyd Renrut
- Total Drama Amazon, by Nalyd Renrut
- Total Drama Craziness, by Goldenshane
- Total Drama Cruise, by Turnertang
- Total Drama Infinity, by DJ Spenstar
- Total Drama Insanity , by DJ Spenstar
- Total Drama Island (Webkinz Mania Style), by Webkinz Mania
- Total Drama Island...?, by Kgman04
- Total Drama Mania, by Anonymos
- Total Drama Mole, by Author999
- Total Drama Pandemonium, by Anonymos
- Total Drama Paradise, by Nalyd Renrut
- Total Drama: Second Chance, by TDIwriter
- Total Drama World, by Nalyd Renrut
- Total Wikia Elementary, by Nalyd Renrut, Sunshineandravioli, and others
- Violet Hill, by Tdiandrockmusic2